Anyway, orca dorsal fins have cartilage in them and thats primarily why skeletons of orca lack the dorsal and caudaltailfin bones when you look at them. Orcas and its effects on human resources 1769 words bartleby. Importantly, the orcas dorsal fin helps to regulate their body temperature. However, in captivity, killer whales are forced to swim in circles in their tiny enclosures, so the water pressure on each side of the dorsal fin is uneven. Are parks like seaworld harming or helping killer whales. National library of medicine at the national institutes of health, most males in captivity have collapsed dorsal fins, but the condition, also known as dorsal fin collapse, flaccid fin, or folded fin syndrome, does occur in many captive females. February 1993 the top 23 of his dorsal fin was collapsed to the animals right at nearly 80 fig.
I am not a shark expert nor a shark professional, rather i am shark enthusiast, diver, and wannabe photographer, who app. A dorsal fin is classified as a medial, unpaired fin that is located on the midline of the backs of some aquatic vertebrates. This fin collapse syndrome is chiefly a peculiarity of captive whales and reflects the fact that they spend an inordinate amount of time either at or near the surface, where th. Dec 29, 2009 collapsed or collapsing dorsal fins are rare in most wild populations and usually result from a serious injury to the fin, such as from being shot or colliding with a vessel. Seaworlds claims about collapsed dorsal fins the s. Have you ever been encaptured by the beauty and magnificence of marine wildlife in a marine park or aquarium.
I would say that fin collapse is a sign of poor health, as well as spending too much time at the surface in tropical or subtropical climates. Seaworld then attempts to pass on the collapsed dorsal fin as a genetic issue rather than one caused by their captivity. Although dorsal fin collapse is not unique to captivity, it is far more common in confinement. But the truth is that this only rarely happens to wild orcas only 1 percent, and when it. Why does the dorsal fin on whales collapse or bend when in. After the 1989 exxon valdez oil spill, the dorsal fins of two male resident killer whales who had been exposed to the oil collapsed, and the animals subsequently died. A dorsal fin is held erect by collagen, which normally hardens in late adolescence. Approximately 1% of wild orcas exhibit fin collapse, where the dorsal fin leans to one side. Excess heat, generated as they swim along, is released into the surrounding water and air via the dorsal fin much like a radiator. Around 151 killer whales have been taken into captivity from the wild since 1961. It is said that less than 1 percent of orcas suffer from dorsal fin collapse in the wild. Oct 01, 2015 however, collapsed dorsal fins are caused by the unnatural environment of captivity and are rarely seen in the wild. One hundred percent of male orcas in captivity have dorsal fins that are partially or completely collapsed to one side, like the one on tilikum pictured here.
I love the effect of the collapsed dorsal fin, it really adds character to seaworlds act of taking care of their animals. Droopy dorsal depression pennsylvania state university. Sea world as asked about the collapsed dorsal fin they claim that it is very common for it to occur in male orcas, but in the wild it is very are. For example, in the wild it can be caused by injury, illness, dehydrations, etc, not just gravity.
The fin is the individuals most distinguishing feature. The flopped dorsal fin you tend to see is called a collapsed condition. Why do the dorsal fins of killer whales sometimes seem to. Pdf the incidence of bent dorsal fins in freeranging cetaceans. A dorsal fin is the 6ft tall black fin that should stand right up on the back of an orca. Seaworld claims that this condition is commonhowever, in the wild, it rarely ever happens and is a sign of an injured or unhealthy orca. All captive adult male orcas have collapsed dorsal fins, likely because they have no space in which to swim freely and are fed an unnatural. Contrary to popular belief, fin collapse doesnt just affect captive whales.
Other reasons for a collapsed dorsal fin are illness and injury, dehydration, the fact that whales in captivity spend most of their time at the surface of the water as opposed to underneath it gravity, and feeding behavior. Collapsed dorsal fins one hundred percent of male orcas in captivity have dorsal fins that are partially or completely collapsed to one side, like the one on tilikum pictured here. In captivity, however, orcas life expectancies are often cut short. Keeping orcas captive demeans us as humans philip hoare seaworld is to end its killer whale shows, but there are still 58 of these intelligent creatures in captivity. A rare occurrence in the wild, fin collapse is exhibited more in whales with poor health, and may result from serious injury, such as an oil spill or a collision. Look at the gallery below, comparing what a dorsal fin should look like and what it looks like in most captive male killer whales. Ingrid vissers 1998 study on fin abnormalities, the percentage rate of wild whales with collapsed, collapsing or bent dorsal fins sits at 4. It also indicates a weakened immunity and severe stress.
She found that 23 percent of the killer whales in new zealand had dorsal fins that were bent, ragged or wavy, only one had total fin collapse. Ultimately, whats going on is the collagen in the dorsal fin is breaking down. The other three passed away in 2004, 2007 and 2008. Keeping orcas captive demeans us as humans philip hoare. Til that the collapsed dorsal fin you see on killer whales in aquatic theme parks like seaworld is usually a consequence of captivity. But the truth is that this only rarely happens to wild orcas only 1 percent, and when it does, its a sign that theyre injured or sick. The collapsed dorsal fins commonly seen in captive killer whales do not result from a pathogenic condition, but are instead thought to most likely originate from an irreversible structural change in the fins collagen over time. The practice of keeping killer whales in captivity is controversial, and organizations such as world animal protection and the whale and dolphin conservation campaign against the captivity of killer whales. Many of the orcas being held in captivity have many problems varying from dental problems, depression, and general health. The number one cause of a collapsed dorsal fin is depression.
Claiming even further that dorsal fins differ between whales because they are unique like humans hair. Jan 28, 2020 according to research published by the u. Faq on seaworlds website assures kids that neither the shape nor the droop of a whales dorsal fin are indicators of a killer whales. Sep 25, 2014 the number one cause of a collapsed dorsal fin is depression. First, almost every whale being held in captivity has a collapsed dorsal fin. Dorsal fin collapse orcas kept in tanks spend most of their time swimming in endless circles, causing their tall dorsal fins to collapse to one side. All captive adult male orcas have collapsed dorsal fins, likely because they have no space in which to swim freely and are fed an unnatural diet of thawed dead fish. Nov 11, 2015 keeping orcas captive demeans us as humans philip hoare seaworld is to end its killer whale shows, but there are still 58 of these intelligent creatures in captivity.
Orcas in captivity may develop physical pathologies, such as the dorsal fin collapse seen in 8090% of captive males. As his manmade pond vanished, taku flopped onto his side, his. This is probably the most extreme case of it, but a good pic of it. Captivity has a range of inherent undesirable problems for orcas, including but not limited to aspects that may affect the upright position of the dorsal fin. Science insider tells you all you need to know about. All of those things are a result of being held in captivity.
Marine biologists attribute this phenomenon to the conditions of their captivity, such as repetitive circular swimming patterns. Tilikum, the orca that is the subject of the movie blackfish, suffers from dorsal fin collapse and his behavior could be reasonably interpreted to. Pdf laterally bent dorsal fins are rarely observed in freeranging populations of cetaceans, contrary to captivity, where most killer whale. Nakai is one of the only captive males over the age of 10 to not have a collapsed dorsal fin, other males such as ikaika and trua are younger, have shorter fins, and have fully collapsed dorsal fins. Most of the men smoked nervously as they watched the black dorsal fin circle the pen. The disgusting truth of orca treatment at seaworld influencive.
Beneath the surface quotes by john hargrovepage 2 of 3. Til that the collapsed dorsal fin you see on killer whales. Sep 01, 2015 while collapsed dorsal fins can occur in the wild it is very, very rare and usually indicates sickness of some kind. Among the males orcas in captivity 100% of them have collapsed dorsal fins, while in the wild collapsed dorsal fin is a rare occurrence. However, collapsed dorsal fins are caused by the unnatural environment of captivity and are rarely seen in the wild.
Even though captivity is a major cause of flaccid fin syndrome in male orcas, it is not the only cause. Mar, 2019 seaworld then attempts to pass on the collapsed dorsal fin as a genetic issue rather than one caused by their captivity. It should also be noted that wild individuals with collapsed dorsals are often ill or close to death, according to researchers. Other animals may not recognize a killer whale until its too late. Today, many orcas are living in captivity educating people. David kirby on captive orcas and his book, death at seaworld. Reasons orcas dont belong at seaworld collapsed dorsal. The short answer is that, in the wild, at least, it almost never is. In the picture on the left, its actually katinas dorsal that theyre measuring. Oct 03, 2012 former seaworld trainer jeff ventre, now a medical doctor and a critic of seaworld, told wired, in captivity, 100 percent of all male dorsal fins are collapsed, and most of the females, too.
These statistics, looked at side by side, further the popular claim that captivity is detrimental to orcas. Sea world as asked about the collapsed dorsal fin they claim that it is very common for it to occur in male orcas, but in the wild it. All captive adult male orcas suffer from collapsed dorsal fins, which is likely caused by the lack of space they have within their enclosures. Seaworld tries to claim to be normal and says in the wild it is a common deformity as well, but in the wild, only 23% of whales have the same collapsed fin. In chapter 15, author jason colby describes a scene of captive orca. Captivity induced dorsal fin collapse isnt thought to be painful or detrimental to orcas health, however.
All the captive male orcas at seaworld have a collapsed dorsal fin, and the company has said that this is a common and naturally occurring problem. In captivity, all the orcas are feral childrenthey had no adult orcas to. Only 1 to 5 percent of male orcas in some populations and none in others have fully collapsed dorsal fins swoh. Former seaworld trainer jeff ventre, now a medical doctor and a critic of seaworld, told wired, in captivity, 100 percent of all male dorsal fins are collapsed, and most of the females, too. In development of the embryo in teleost fish, the dorsal fin arises from sections of the skin that form a caudal fin fold. Experts agree that a collapsed dorsal fin indicates sickness from being kept in cramped or unnatural conditions. Sep 14, 2015 the collapsed dorsal fins commonly seen in captive killer whales do not result from a pathogenic condition, but are instead thought to most likely originate from an irreversible structural change in the fins collagen over time. Captive killer whales are live killer whales orcinus orca which are held in captivity by humans. Jeffrey ventre md, a former killer whale trainer, is filming, and david kirby is asking questions. Comparison between a captive orcas dorsal and a wild ones. Looking down from above, the black on the dorsal side mixes with the dark ocean.
Despite the fact that the dorsal fin is very straight, it is supported not by bone but a fibrous connective tissue called collagen. After watching the 20 documentary blackfish directed by gabriela cowperthwaite, the. In the wild, the condition varies from population to population. In the wild, killer whales can live between 50 and 80 years. After killing trainer keltie byrne, tilikum would be transferred to seaworld orlando, where he would ultimately kill two more people. Less than 1% of orcas in the wild have collapsed dorsal fins while in captivity, it is unnaturally common. So not only killer whales in captivity have collapsed fins. Have you ever noticed how all the show orcas have collapsed dorsal fins. A vital look at orcas in captivity the village voice. Laterally bent dorsal fins are rarely observed in freeranging populations of cetaceans, contrary to captivity, where most killer whale orcinus orca adult males have laterally collapsed fins. In the wild, dorsal fin collapse is extremely rare, but all adult male orcas in captivity have fully collapsed dorsal fins and many females fins are partially collapsed. A partial or complete collapse of a dorsal fin is seen most prominently in male orcas although some captive females do have a partial or complete collapse of their dorsal fin.
The whale and dolphin conservation says that dorsal fin collapse is largely explained by captive killer whales swimming. In captivity, it is most likely going to be caused by gravity and lack of water pressure, but its better to be safe and take the health of the orca seriously, which would mean taking bent. One hundred percent of captive male whales have either partially or fully collapsed dorsal fins. The largest male orca in captivity, tilikum was easily identified by his collapsed dorsal fin. I love the effect of the collapsed dorsal fin, it really adds character to. Dorsal fin collapse has been observed in 1% of wild orcas. Collapsed or collapsing dorsal fins are rare in most wild populations and usually result from a serious injury to the fin, such as from being shot or colliding with a vessel. After the death of brancheau in 2010, tilikum spent much of his time in isolation away from trainers and other whales. A look at killer whales in captivity by anoorca on deviantart. Look at the gallery below, comparing what a dorsal fin should look like. Male killer whales have much larger dorsal fins in comparison to females, in fact males are twice the size of females growing to around 6ft, the males dorsal fin is more of a triangular shape whereas a females is shorter and more curved. The dorsal fin is a blog that will deal with shark news and the promotion of responsible shark conservation.
Collapsed dorsal fins killer whales pictures cbs news. The worlds biggest dolphins killer whales pictures cbs. The captive environment bears little resemblance to their wild habitat, and the social groups that the killer whales are put into are foreign to those found in the wild. Its mostly caused by depression and what food the whales are. This is a wild killer whale with a bent back or collapsed fin. Many of the female orcas in captivity have these collapsed dorsal fins as well. Though seaworld claims, neither the shape nor the droop. All males in captivity have collapsed dorsal fins, but the condition, also known as dorsal fin collapse, flaccid fin, or folded fin syndrome. For orcas, the dorsal fin is actually an indicator of several problems associated with life in captivity. This orca needs to have a collapsed dorsal fin so i can get that real experience of viewing the orcas in captivity at seaworld. Laterally bent dorsal fins are rarely observed in freeranging populations of cetaceans, contrary to captivity, where most killer whale. Buy products related to dorsal fin products and see what customers say about dorsal fin products on free delivery possible on eligible purchases. This is a killer whale in captivity with a bent back fin or collapsed fin. Dorsal fin collapse happens for a variety of reasons.
Five were taken into captivity, the other five were driven back out to sea. Nov 09, 2011 approximately 1% of wild orcas exhibit fin collapse, where the dorsal fin leans to one side. The health awareness is a large reason why orcas should not be kept in confinement. Jeffrey ventre md, a former killer whale trainer, is. Biologists think there are several reasons for the phenomenon. Reasons orcas dont belong at seaworld collapsed dorsal fins. At the end of the day, whales do not belong in captivity. After the 1989 exxon valdez oil spill, the dorsal fins of two male resident orcas who had been exposed to the oil collapsed, and the animals subsequently died. Dorsal fin collapse most captive male killer whales, and some females, have a dorsal fin that is partially or completely collapsed to one side. By june 1997, two of the captured orcas had alread died. For more on the dorsal fin collapse, watch the following interview with david kirby and dr. The collapsed dorsal fin is very rare in the wild, only 25% of whales have it. Looking up from below, the white on the ventral side blends into the sunlit water. He died on january 6, 2017 after 34 years in captivity.
The trailing edge of the dorsal fin was wavy and the front had a large notch near the bending point. May 29, 2015 a dorsal fin is the 6ft tall black fin that should stand right up on the back of an orca. Its obvious that something is wrong, or at least different, when you see an orca with a dorsal fin bent all the way over. This whale blue plush does not represent the types of orcas in care at seaworld.
788 1217 197 601 584 1397 1111 1093 763 1491 1190 1369 516 219 390 1380 140 1036 642 524 515 504 1291 913 726 166 781 1188 1380 741 1381 546 1086 937 360 30 1038 1222 548